Kerala High Court Tells CBFC: Judge Films as an Ordinary Viewer, Not a Hypersensitive One
In a significant ruling that could influence film censorship practices across India, the Kerala High Court has directed the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) to grant certification to the Malayalam film Haal, starring Shane Nigam.
The court emphasized that films must be evaluated from the viewpoint of a reasonable, ordinary viewer, not someone who is hypersensitive or overly reactive. This directive limits arbitrary demands for edits or deletions that may not align with the real sentiments of general audiences.
Why Haal Faced Certification Issues
The CBFC had earlier insisted that the makers of Haal implement multiple modifications and cuts. These included the removal of certain scenes, one of which involved a character eating beef biryani, a depiction the board believed could trigger sensitivities.
However, the filmmakers challenged these instructions, arguing that the story showcased reality in a natural, non-provocative manner.
What the Kerala High Court Observed
The court noted the following key points:
Creative freedom cannot be restricted based on extreme or hypersensitive interpretations.
Cinema is a reflection of society, and portraying everyday cultural elements does not amount to provocation.
The CBFC's role is not to impose excessive caution but to ensure broad public safety and sensibility.
Artistic expression should be viewed through the lens of a common, rational viewer, not through isolated or extreme opinions.
This ruling reinforces past judicial observations that freedom of expression in films must be preserved unless content genuinely threatens public order.
Impact on the Malayalam Film Industry
Malayalam cinema has long been known for bold themes and realistic storytelling. The Kerala HC’s judgement is expected to:
Boost creative confidence among filmmakers
Reduce unnecessary censorship interventions
Streamline the film certification process
Encourage more grounded narratives without fear of avoidable cuts
Haal is now expected to release soon, with audiences eager to see Shane Nigam in this anticipated performance.
Why This Story Went Trending Fast on Google
This development quickly climbed Google Trends because:
It involves free speech, censorship, and cinema, high-interest topics in India.
Shane Nigam has a strong youth fanbase.
The beef biryani scene became a point of national discussion on cultural representation.
High court rulings related to creative freedom often gain rapid online traction.
Vizzve Finance’s news syndication and SEO-optimized distribution helped the story index quickly and gain visibility.
FAQ Section
1. Why did the CBFC reject Haal initially?
The CBFC demanded multiple edits, including deleting a scene showing beef biryani, citing potential sensitivities.
2. What did the Kerala High Court say?
The court stated that films should be evaluated from the perspective of an ordinary person, not someone who is hypersensitive. It directed the CBFC to certify Haal.
3. What does this ruling mean for Indian cinema?
It strengthens artistic freedom and reduces arbitrary censorship. Filmmakers can portray realistic cultural settings without fear of disproportionate cuts.
4. Is Haal cleared for release?
Yes, the court has instructed the CBFC to issue certification.
5. Why was this news trending on Google?
The case touches on free speech, cinema censorship, cultural debates, and a major Malayalam star—topics that quickly gain traction online.
Published on : 15TH November
Published by : SARANYA
Source Credit ; Shaju Philip
🛡 Powered by Vizzve Financial
RBI-Registered Loan Partner | 10 Lakh+ Customers | ₹600 Cr+ Disbursed